Compare your options
Pay-as-you-go workers' comp vs an annual premium audit
Pay-as-you-go doesn't skip the audit. The Hartford puts it plainly: "No, having pay-as-you-go workers' comp doesn't prevent your business from having an audit." What it changes is billing: your premium is worked out from actual payroll each pay period, so the year-end adjustment is usually small (ERGO NEXT says the annual audit is "fast, easy" with little to no adjustment). If your payroll grows or swings during the year and your insurer and payroll provider offer it, switching billing is a better fix for a big audit bill than any kit, ours included. Our kit still helps with the audit you face now, and with subcontractor certificates: The Hartford notes that you still collect certificates of insurance from subcontractors, and the audit checks they had coverage.
Side by side
From each option's own pages, as of Nov 2026. "Partly" cells say what is and isn't covered.
| What you get | Workers Comp Audit Prep kit | ERGO NEXT pay-as-you-go workers' comp | The Hartford pay-as-you-go workers' comp | Traditional billing with an annual audit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premium billed on actual payroll each pay periodThe premium is worked out from each payroll run, not a yearly estimate. | — NoNot insurance: the kit doesn't change how you are billed. | ✓ YesCalculated from actual payroll data every pay cycle. | ✓ YesPremium based on actual payroll. | — NoBased on estimated payroll, trued up at the audit. |
| Year-end premium audit still happensThe insurer still checks payroll, class codes and subcontractors after the policy year. | ✓ YesYour policy's audit still happens; the kit prepares the file for it. | ✓ YesThey say the annual audit is "fast, easy" with little to no adjustment. | ✓ Yes"No, having pay-as-you-go workers' comp doesn't prevent your business from having an audit." | ✓ YesThe audit can bring a balance due, a refund or policy changes. |
| Smaller or no down paymentLess cash up front than a deposit on estimated annual payroll. | — NoNot insurance: it doesn't change your deposit. | ✓ YesNo down payment. | ◐ PartlySmaller deposit, but not zero. | — NoUsually a deposit on the estimated annual premium. |
| Needs a payroll provider that supports itOnly works when your payroll company and insurer are set up for it. | — NoNot tied to a payroll provider. | ✓ YesQuickBooks, Square, Gusto, Toast, Rippling and other partners. | ✓ YesNot all payroll companies and insurers offer it. | — NoWorks with any payroll setup. |
| Helps you build the audit file before the auditRecords gathered, reconciled and indexed before the auditor asks. | ✓ YesWorkbook with reconciliation sheets; checklist and packet structure in the $149 and $299 kits. | — NoNot described on their page. | — NoNot described on their page. | — NoThe carrier sends a records request; preparing is up to you. |
| Subcontractor certificate (COI) trackingA place to log subcontractor certificates of insurance and their dates. | ◐ PartlyFull COI tracker in the Construction Kit; light in the SMB Edition. | — NoNot described for subcontractors on their page. | — NoYou still collect certificates of insurance from subcontractors, and the audit checks they had coverage. | — NoYou collect subcontractor certificates yourself. |
| Price (as listed on their page) | $19 one-time Audit Prep Workbook$149 one-time SMB Edition$299 one-time Construction Kit | Premium worked out from actual payroll each pay cycle; quote-based Pay-as-you-go billing | Premium paid each pay period on actual payroll; quote-based Pay-as-you-go billing | Deposit of 25% to 100% of the estimated annual premium Deposit on estimated payroll, then installments |
Who each option suits
Pick ERGO NEXT pay-as-you-go workers' comp if
Small businesses whose payroll company is one of NEXT's partners and whose headcount or hours swing during the year.
- Premium follows actual payroll, so the year-end adjustment is small.
- No large deposit tied up for the year.
- Payments run automatically with payroll.
Not for: Businesses whose payroll provider doesn't connect to NEXT, or who want to stay with their current carrier.
Pick The Hartford pay-as-you-go workers' comp if
Businesses that want one bill each pay period, combined with payroll, and a smaller deposit.
- Less likely to face a year-end adjustment from underreported payroll.
- Smaller deposit than traditional billing.
- One combined bill with payroll.
Not for: Owners who want to watch the true cost of their coverage closely; The Hartford says you may lose some direct view of it.
Stay on traditional billing if
Businesses with steady payroll, where the estimate at the start of the year is close to what really happens.
- Available with any carrier and any payroll provider.
- Nothing to set up between payroll and insurer.
Not for: Businesses whose payroll grows or swings during the year; the audit can then bring a large bill.
Pick our kit if
- Your audit is coming up now, under the policy you already have.
- You have subcontractors, and their certificates of insurance are the part most likely to raise the bill.
- Your payroll provider doesn't support pay-as-you-go, or you want to stay with your carrier.
- You want a fixed price you know today: $19, $149, $299, one-time, with a 14-day refund window.
Where we're weaker
- No one reviews your numbers for you.
- We don't talk to your carrier, auditor or rating bureau.
- We don't give class-code, legal or insurance advice.
- We can't recover overpayments from past years.
- Pay-as-you-go billing changes how you're billed, so a big audit bill is less likely; our kit can't change your bill.
When switching avoids the big audit bill
The big audit bill usually comes from the gap between the payroll estimated at the start of the policy and the payroll you really paid. Pay-as-you-go closes most of that gap during the year, because each pay period's premium follows that pay period's payroll.
- Your payroll grew during the year, or you hire for busy seasons.
- Your payroll company is one the insurer connects to.
- Your insurer and payroll provider both offer it; ask them whether it is available and when you can switch.
When the kit still helps
Billing changes don't touch the parts of the audit that aren't payroll totals: class codes for each worker, owner and officer pay, and proof that each subcontractor had its own coverage. The Hartford notes the audit still checks that your subcontractors had workers' comp coverage, whichever way you pay.
If the audit bill has already arrived, switching billing for next year doesn't change it. Check each line first; our free guides show how.
Prices side by side (as of Nov 2026)
| Option | Plan | Price | Limits and terms | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Workers Comp Audit Prep kit | Audit Prep Workbook | $19 one-time | The two blank Excel workbooks only; 14-day refund window | Nov 4, 2026 |
| Workers Comp Audit Prep kit | SMB Edition | $149 one-time | Lighter kit for office, retail and service businesses; 14-day refund window | Nov 4, 2026 |
| Workers Comp Audit Prep kit | Construction Kit | $299 one-time | Full contractor kit with COI tracker and packet index; 14-day refund window | Nov 4, 2026 |
| ERGO NEXT pay-as-you-go workers' comp | Pay-as-you-go billing | Premium worked out from actual payroll each pay cycle; quote-based | No down payment; signup through one of 100+ payroll partners | Nov 4, 2026 |
| The Hartford pay-as-you-go workers' comp | Pay-as-you-go billing | Premium paid each pay period on actual payroll; quote-based | "Some cash up front, just not as much as a traditional plan" | Nov 4, 2026 |
| Traditional billing with an annual audit | Deposit on estimated payroll, then installments | Deposit of 25% to 100% of the estimated annual premium | NEXT's comparison table gives 25% to 100%; The Hartford says you may have to put down 25% | Nov 4, 2026 |
Frequently asked questions
Does pay-as-you-go workers' comp still get audited?
Yes. The Hartford: "No, having pay-as-you-go workers' comp doesn't prevent your business from having an audit." ERGO NEXT says the annual audit is "fast, easy" with little to no adjustment.
Is pay-as-you-go a different kind of insurance?
No. It is a way of paying for the same workers' comp coverage, so your policy, class codes and audit rules stay the same. Your coverage still comes from a workers' comp insurer.
Do I need a down payment?
It depends on the insurer. ERGO NEXT pay-as-you-go workers' comp: no down payment. The Hartford: smaller deposit, but not zero. With traditional billing, expect a deposit of 25% to 100% of the estimated annual premium (NEXT's comparison table gives 25% to 100%; The Hartford says you may have to put down 25%).
Will switching fix the audit bill I already have?
No. Switching changes how future premium is billed. An audit that is already finished is checked and disputed on its own terms; start with the bill check and dispute letter guides.
Is this legal or insurance advice?
No. This page compares billing options from the insurers' own published pages, checked on the dates shown. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice; ask your agent or carrier what your policy allows.
Sources
Every fact about another company on this page comes from these pages, checked on the dates shown.
- ERGO NEXT pay-as-you-go workers' comp: nextinsurance.com/workers-compensation-insurance/edu/pay-as-you-go-workers-comp/ (checked Nov 4, 2026)
- The Hartford pay-as-you-go workers' comp: thehartford.com/workers-compensation/pay-as-you-go-workers-comp (checked Nov 4, 2026)
- Traditional billing with an annual audit: nextinsurance.com/workers-compensation-insurance/edu/pay-as-you-go-workers-comp/ (checked Nov 4, 2026)
- Traditional billing with an annual audit: employers.com/resources/faqs/premium-audit-faqs/ (checked Nov 4, 2026)
- Traditional billing with an annual audit: thehartford.com/workers-compensation/pay-as-you-go-workers-comp (checked Nov 4, 2026)
Spotted an error? Email support@sblocktechnologies.com and we will fix it within a week. That includes the companies on this page.
No ratings or reviews here: we haven't used these services ourselves, so we only report what their own pages say. This is not legal, tax or insurance advice.