Audit dispute letter
A free letter to copy when the audit bill is wrong, with wording and evidence for each item.
Learn more →Audit bill check
An audit bill is payroll times rates, adjusted by a few factors. Here is what each line on the audit report means, what goes wrong on it, and the record that fixes it.
Your audit bill is the difference between the premium the auditor calculated from your actual payroll and the deposit premium you already paid. For each class code the premium is payroll divided by 100, times the rate. For example, $200,000 of payroll at a rate of $5.00 is $10,000. The total is then adjusted by your experience mod, credits and discounts, and fixed charges and taxes.
So a surprise bill usually comes from one of a few lines: more payroll than the policy estimated, payroll in a higher rated class code, subcontractors without proof of insurance added as payroll, owner or officer pay, overtime counted in full, a different mod, or the minimum premium. Check each one below against your own records.
Ask the carrier for the audit worksheets if you only have a one-page bill. Rules differ by state and carrier, so check your state guide for overtime, officer limits and the dispute path.
Two words you will see on this site: to reconcile payroll means to check that your payroll totals match your tax forms (Form 941s, W-2s) for the same policy period. A crosswalk is a short table or note that maps each payroll and tax report to the policy period, so you and the auditor can see where each number comes from.
Want to see which line drives your bill? Estimate your audit bill free
Work down your audit report in this order. Mark any line you can prove is wrong, then put it in a dispute letter.
| Line on the audit | What to check | Proof that fixes it |
|---|---|---|
| Policy period and deposit premium | The dates match your policy, and the deposit or estimated premium matches what you actually paid | Declarations page, policy changes and payment history |
| Payroll by class code | Each class total adds up to your payroll for the policy period, not the calendar year. The class codes match the work people did | Payroll register by employee and quarter, Form 941s, and a list of who does what work |
| Clerical and outside sales | Office staff and outside sales staff are in their own low rated codes, not in a field code | Job duties showing they do not work in the field, and payroll split by person |
| Construction payroll split across classes | Under NCCI rules, payroll for one worker can be split across construction classes only if your records show the pay for each type of work. Otherwise it all goes in the highest rated class | Time records or job costing that show hours and pay by type of work |
| Uninsured subcontractors | Which subs were added as payroll and at what amount. Subs without proof of their own coverage are usually charged as if they were your employees | A certificate of insurance from each sub's carrier covering the state and the dates of the work, and the payment list by sub |
| Owner and officer pay | Whether owners or officers are included or excluded, and whether their pay was raised or lowered to the state's minimum or maximum | Any exclusion endorsement or state exemption, officer pay and weeks active, and the state's officer limits |
| Overtime | In most states the extra part of overtime pay (the half in time and a half) is excluded when records show it separately. Pennsylvania counts it all | Payroll register with overtime premium in its own column |
| Experience mod | The mod on the audit matches the mod your rating bureau calculated for this policy period. The auditor does not set the mod | The experience rating worksheet, from your agent or rating bureau |
| Credits, discounts and fixed charges | Schedule credits, premium discount, expense constant and state taxes or surcharges match the policy. They follow the premium, so they change when it changes | Declarations page and rating pages of the policy |
| Minimum premium | If the audited premium is low, the bill may show the policy minimum instead, usually set by the highest minimum among your class codes | The minimum premium shown on the declarations page |
| Estimated or noncompliance charge | A line saying the audit was estimated or that an audit noncompliance charge was applied because records were not provided | The full set of records the auditor asked for, sent with a request to replace the estimate |
A free letter to copy when the audit bill is wrong, with wording and evidence for each item.
Learn more →NCCI rules, owner coverage, contractors and the appeals board.
Learn more →The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.
Learn more →Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.
Learn more →NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.
Learn more →One-employee rule, officer opt-outs, uninsured subs and appeals.
Learn more →Usually because actual payroll was higher than the estimate on the policy, payroll landed in a higher rated class code, or subcontractors without proof of insurance were added as payroll. Owner or officer pay, overtime and a changed mod can add to it.
For each class code, payroll divided by 100 times the rate. The total is adjusted by the experience mod, credits and discounts, then fixed charges and taxes are added. The bill is that audited premium minus the deposit premium you already paid.
In most states the auditor counts what you paid that sub as your payroll in the class for their work, unless you can show they had their own coverage for the time they worked for you.
No. The mod is calculated by the rating bureau from your payroll and claims history. If the mod on the audit does not match the rating worksheet for that policy period, ask the carrier and your agent to correct it.
Yes. If actual payroll was lower than estimated, the audit can show return premium, as long as the total stays above the policy's minimum premium.
Write to the carrier with the line, the correct figure and the record that proves it. The free dispute letter template on this site is laid out for that.
Official rating bureau and state agency pages this guide is based on.
This page gives general guidance for reading an audit bill. It is not legal or insurance advice, and your policy, your state's rules and your carrier's audit are the final word.
Run your payroll through the free estimator, then tie each audit line to the record that supports it: the Construction Kit if you are a contractor, the SMB Edition for restaurants, offices, shops and other small businesses.