Compare your options

Audit prep kit vs a premium audit consultant vs your CPA

If you want a person to check a finished audit and deal with the carrier, a premium audit consultant does that: Reliable Premium Management (Audit Reviews) reviews audits for $40 an hour (flat hourly rate; they say most audits are finished in under 2 hours), usually through your agent or CPA, and Premium Paybacks recovers overpaid premiums from past years on a contingent fee: you pay only if and when they collect. If your accountant already runs your payroll, ask them first, because auditors ask for 941s, state unemployment forms and a payroll journal, reports your payroll provider or accountant can pull. Your carrier's own audit pages are free and tell you what to send. Our kit ($19, $149, $299, one-time) is for doing the prep yourself before the audit: a workbook, checklist and packet structure. No one reviews your numbers for you, and that is the main thing it lacks.

Side by side

From each option's own pages, as of Nov 2026. "Partly" cells say what is and isn't covered.

Audit prep kit, premium audit consultants, your CPA and the carrier's free help, compared
What you getWorkers Comp Audit Prep kitReliable Premium Management (Audit Reviews)Premium PaybacksYour CPA or bookkeeperYour carrier's free audit help (EMPLOYERS, for example)
A person reviews your numbersSomeone other than you checks payroll, class codes and the audit result.✓ YesAudit specialists check class codes, dates, experience mod, overtime, exemptions and more.✓ YesReviews class codes, discounts and deductions, and overcharges.◐ PartlyDepends on what you hire them for.◐ PartlyTheir premium auditor reviews your payroll, for the insurer.
Helps you build the audit file before the auditRecords gathered, reconciled and indexed before the auditor asks.— NoTheir page describes reviewing audits after the policy ends.— NoTheir pages describe recovery of past premiums, not audit prep.◐ PartlyAuditors ask for 941s, state unemployment forms and a payroll journal, reports your payroll provider or accountant can pull.◐ PartlyLists the records (941s, state unemployment forms, payroll journal) and gives a voluntary audit form.
Reviews the bill after the auditChecks a finished audit or invoice for errors.✓ YesReviews audit results and explains audit balances.✓ YesReviews past policies and reports overcharges; one to seven years back, depending on the error.◐ PartlySome CPA firms use an audit-review service for this (Reliable Premium Management lists CPA firms as clients).◐ PartlyYou can ask for a copy of the auditor's report and dispute the result in writing.
Deals with the carrier for youWrites to or calls the insurer or rating bureau on your behalf.✓ YesCoordinates with most carriers on balances and refunds; full dispute support.✓ YesCorresponds with the carrier and the rating bureau or NCCI for you.◐ PartlyDepends on the engagement.— NoThey are the carrier.
Price known before you startYou know what you will pay before any work begins.◐ PartlyHourly rate is published; the total depends on the hours.◐ PartlyNo fee unless they collect; the percentage isn't on their site.◐ PartlyAsk for a quote.✓ YesFree.
Templates and checklists you keepFiles you own and can reuse next year.— NoNot described on their page.— NoNot described on their pages.— NoNot a standard deliverable.◐ PartlyVoluntary audit form and instructions to download.
Subcontractor certificate (COI) trackingA place to log subcontractor certificates of insurance and their dates.— NoNot described on their page.— NoNot described on their pages.— NoNot a standard deliverable.— NoNot described on their FAQ.
Price (as listed on their page)$40 an hour Audit reviewContingent fee: you pay only if and when they collect Premium recoveryQuoted by the firm Your own firmFree Premium audit FAQ, voluntary audit form and instructions

Who each option suits

Pick Reliable Premium Management (Audit Reviews) if

Small to mid-sized businesses with fluctuating payroll, several class codes or a past audit dispute. The program is built for insurance agents and CPAs to use for their clients.

  • A specialist reviews the audit for you, which our kit never does.
  • They can dispute a finding and deal with the carrier on your behalf.
  • Published hourly rate, in all 50 states and DC.

Not for: Someone who only wants a do-it-yourself file and templates to keep; the service is a person reviewing a finished audit.

Their page

Pick Premium Paybacks if

Businesses that think they have overpaid workers' comp premiums in past years and want someone else to find and recover the money.

  • No cost to you unless they recover money.
  • They can look back up to seven years, depending on the error.
  • Their staff do the work; they say they don't sell insurance.

Not for: Someone preparing records for an audit that hasn't happened yet; their pages describe recovering past overpayments.

Their page

Pick your CPA or bookkeeper if

Businesses whose accountant already runs payroll and the quarterly filings, and can pull the records an auditor asks for.

  • They already know your books and payroll.
  • A professional can check figures and answer follow-up questions.
  • Ask up front what the engagement covers: gathering records, checking class codes, or talking to the auditor.

Not for: Anyone expecting a class-code or premium-rating review by default; that depends on the firm, and some bring in an audit-review service for it.

Pick your carrier's free audit help if

Policyholders with a simple payroll who only need to know what to send and by when.

  • Free, and it is the carrier's own word on what to send.
  • Explains overtime, Section 125 and dispute steps for its own policies.

Not for: Anyone who wants help on their side of the table: the carrier's auditor works for the insurer.

Their page

Pick our kit if

  • You or your office manager will gather the records yourselves and want a clear order to do it in.
  • The audit hasn't happened yet, so there is still time to reconcile payroll and chase missing certificates.
  • You are a contractor with subcontractors and want a COI tracker and packet index (Construction Kit).
  • You want a fixed price you know today: $19, $149, $299, one-time, with a 14-day refund window.

Where we're weaker

  • No one reviews your numbers for you.
  • We don't talk to your carrier, auditor or rating bureau.
  • We don't give class-code, legal or insurance advice.
  • We can't recover overpayments from past years.
  • Reliable Premium Management checks your numbers; our kit only gives you the tools to check them yourself.
  • Reliable Premium Management works with the carrier for you; we don't contact anyone.
  • Premium Paybacks can recover money from past policies; our kit can't.
  • Premium Paybacks does the review and the carrier correspondence; we leave both to you.
  • Your accountant can look at your actual numbers; our kit can't.
  • Your accountant can answer the auditor's follow-up questions for you.
  • Your carrier's audit help is free; our kit costs $19 to $299.
  • Your carrier's pages describe its actual process; ours are general guides.

You can use more than one

These options aren't exclusive. A common order: build the file yourself before the audit (with our kit or your carrier's list), then, if the bill still looks wrong, pay a consultant to review it. A tidy file also means fewer billable hours for whoever reviews it.

If the bill has already arrived, start with our free guides: check each line of the bill, then use the dispute letter. They cost nothing and tell you whether paying for a review is worth it.

Prices side by side (as of Nov 2026)

OptionPlanPriceLimits and termsChecked
Workers Comp Audit Prep kitAudit Prep Workbook$19 one-timeThe two blank Excel workbooks only; 14-day refund windowNov 4, 2026
Workers Comp Audit Prep kitSMB Edition$149 one-timeLighter kit for office, retail and service businesses; 14-day refund windowNov 4, 2026
Workers Comp Audit Prep kitConstruction Kit$299 one-timeFull contractor kit with COI tracker and packet index; 14-day refund windowNov 4, 2026
Reliable Premium Management (Audit Reviews)Audit review$40 an hourFlat hourly rate; they say most audits are finished in under 2 hoursNov 4, 2026
Premium PaybacksPremium recoveryContingent fee: you pay only if and when they collectFee percentage not published on their siteNov 4, 2026
Your CPA or bookkeeperYour own firmQuoted by the firmNo public price list; each firm sets its own feeNov 4, 2026
Your carrier's free audit help (EMPLOYERS, for example)Premium audit FAQ, voluntary audit form and instructionsFreeFor EMPLOYERS policyholders; other carriers publish their ownNov 4, 2026

Frequently asked questions

How do premium audit consultants charge?

It varies by firm. Reliable Premium Management (Audit Reviews) lists $40 an hour (flat hourly rate; they say most audits are finished in under 2 hours). Premium Paybacks works on a contingent fee: you pay only if and when they collect (fee percentage not published on their site). Ask any firm for its fee in writing before you sign.

Will your kit review my numbers?

No. Nobody reviews your numbers. Support covers access, downloads and workbook use, not audit consulting. The kit gives you the workbook, checklist and packet structure to check them yourself.

Should I just ask my CPA?

Often, yes, if they already run your payroll. Auditors ask for 941s, state unemployment forms and a payroll journal, reports your payroll provider or accountant can pull. Whether they also check class codes or talk to the auditor depends on what you hire them for.

Isn't the carrier's auditor checking my numbers anyway?

Yes, but for the insurer. Carrier pages such as EMPLOYERS' premium audit FAQ are free and say what to send; on EMPLOYERS' page, you can ask for a copy of the auditor's report and dispute the result in writing. A consultant or your CPA works on your side.

Is this legal or insurance advice?

No. This page compares services from their own published pages, checked on the dates shown. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, and your policy and your carrier's audit are the final word.

Sources

Every fact about another company on this page comes from these pages, checked on the dates shown.

Reliable Premium Management (Audit Reviews): Their own domain did not load on Nov 4, 2026; facts come from the Audit Reviews page they publish on CompleteMarkets, written in their own voice.

Your CPA or bookkeeper: No source publishes CPA fees for audit help, so this row says that rather than guess a price.

Spotted an error? Email support@sblocktechnologies.com and we will fix it within a week. That includes the companies on this page.

No ratings or reviews here: we haven't used these services ourselves, so we only report what their own pages say. This is not legal, tax or insurance advice.