Arizona workers' comp audit

Workers' comp audits in Arizona: NCCI rules, owners and disputes

Arizona uses NCCI's manuals and rate filings. Here is who needs coverage, how owners and officers count, and how to dispute an audit.

Quick answer

Arizona is an NCCI state. Under A.R.S. 20-359, every insurer must follow the filings of the rating organization it belongs to, though it may file set percentage deviations and a schedule rating plan. NCCI publishes the Basic Manual for Arizona that sets class codes and payroll rules.

Any employer that regularly employs workers in its usual business must carry coverage, even with one worker. Part-time workers, minors and family members count. Working shareholders and LLC members who own less than 50% count as employees. Owners of 50% or more, sole proprietors and working partners are covered only if the carrier accepts their written application by endorsement.

If you disagree with your audit, work it out with the carrier first and pay the undisputed premium. You can then use NCCI's dispute process, or send a written request to Arizona's Workers' Compensation Appeals Board at the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI). You can appeal the Board's decision to the DIFI Director within 30 days after it mails its decision.

Email me the Arizona audit checklist

The free checklist PDF, plus how Arizona counts payroll at audit, in one email.

How Arizona counts payroll at audit

From A.R.S. Title 20 and Title 23, the Industrial Commission of Arizona (ICA) and NCCI's Arizona instructions (as of 9/14/2024). Ask your agent for the officer payroll limits in your carrier's filed manual.

ItemArizona ruleWhat to keep
Who must carry coverageAny employer that regularly employs workers in its usual business, whatever the number. Part-time workers, minors and family members count. Domestic servants in your home are exemptA list of everyone on payroll by month, with part-time staff and family members marked
Class codesInsurers must follow the filings of their rating organization (NCCI) under A.R.S. 20-359. They may file up to six percentage deviations and a schedule rating planA short description of what each employee actually does
Corporate officers and LLC membersWorking shareholders and LLC members who own less than 50% are employees. NCCI treats LLC members like corporate officers. Officers are covered unless they reject coverage in writing, and the carrier excludes payroll only for those who reject. Ask your agent for the current officer payroll limitsOwnership percentages, officer pay, and a copy of each written rejection the carrier received
Owners of 50% or more, sole proprietors and partnersCovered only if the carrier accepts a written application by endorsement. Premium is based on an assumed monthly wage of at least $600, up to the maximum wage in A.R.S. 23-1041The endorsement and the assumed wage the carrier approved
Independent contractors and subcontractorsA subcontractor you supervise or control on work that is part of your business counts as your employee. A carrier may not charge premium for a contractor it calls an employee unless it gives you written audit findings firstSigned contractor agreements, sole proprietor waivers and certificates of insurance
Overtime and tipsArizona's official pages do not publish a separate rule. Ask your carrier how your policy treats overtime premium, tips and service chargesPayroll register with overtime premium and tips in their own columns

Arizona-specific mistakes

  • Thinking a business with one or two workers does not need coverage
  • Leaving working shareholders or LLC members who own less than 50% off the payroll report
  • Assuming an officer is excluded when no written rejection was filed with the carrier
  • Assuming an owner, sole proprietor or partner is covered without a carrier endorsement
  • Paying for contractors without a signed written agreement or a sole proprietor waiver that the carrier also signed
  • Not collecting certificates of insurance from subcontractors for the dates of their work
  • Missing the 30-day window to appeal an Appeals Board decision to the DIFI Director

Arizona audit checklist

  1. List everyone you regularly employ, including part-time workers, family members and working owners, with each owner's percentage.
  2. Pull payroll by employee and class for the policy period, with overtime premium shown separately.
  3. Keep tips, service charges and automatic gratuities in separate columns, and ask your carrier how each is treated.
  4. Find every officer or member rejection of coverage and every owner endorsement on file with the carrier.
  5. Gather signed independent contractor agreements and any sole proprietor waivers signed by your carrier.
  6. Collect certificates of insurance for every subcontractor for the dates of the work.
  7. Check the final audit results line by line, and ask for written findings on any contractor the auditor moved to payroll.

How an Arizona audit dispute works

From NCCI's dispute resolution process and A.R.S. 20-367.01.

  1. Try to resolve the dispute directly with your carrier, in writing, with the records that support your position. You may ask the carrier or NCCI, in writing, for the information behind your rate. They may charge a reasonable fee.
  2. Pay the carrier all undisputed premium that is due, and give it an estimate of the premium in dispute with a written explanation.
  3. If that fails and the dispute is about NCCI manual rules (class codes, payroll allocation or the experience mod), ask NCCI's Dispute Resolution Services to review it.
  4. You may also send a written request to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board at DIFI to review how the rating system was applied to your policy. If the Board does not act within 30 days, you may proceed as if it rejected your request. You pay the cost to record the hearing.
  5. If you disagree with the Board, appeal to the DIFI Director within 30 days after the Board mails its decision. The Director holds a hearing with at least 10 days' written notice and may affirm, modify or reverse the decision.

Keep reading

More on this topic

California audit rules

The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.

Learn more →

Florida audit rules

Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.

Learn more →

Georgia audit rules

NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Illinois audit rules

One-employee rule, officer opt-outs, uninsured subs and appeals.

Learn more →

Indiana audit rules

ICRB rules, officer elections, contractor certificates and disputes.

Learn more →

Maryland audit rules

NCCI rules, officer exclusions, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Frequently asked questions

Does Arizona require workers' comp insurance?

Yes, for any employer that regularly employs workers in its usual business, even one part-time worker. Domestic servants who work in your home and workers whose job is both casual and outside your usual business are exempt.

Does Arizona use NCCI class codes?

Yes. NCCI is the rating organization for Arizona and publishes the Basic Manual for Arizona. Under A.R.S. 20-359, insurers must follow their rating organization's filings, though they may file percentage deviations and a schedule rating plan.

What are the Arizona executive officer payroll limits?

We did not find the current figures on an official public page. Ask your agent for the minimum and maximum officer payroll in your carrier's filed manual for your policy date. For owners who elect coverage by endorsement, A.R.S. 23-901 sets an assumed wage of at least $600 a month, up to the maximum wage in A.R.S. 23-1041.

Can owners and officers opt out in Arizona?

Corporate officers and LLC members are covered unless they reject coverage. Under A.R.S. 23-906, the rejection must be in writing, signed and dated, given to the employer in duplicate before any injury, and filed by the employer with the carrier within five days. Owners of 50% or more, sole proprietors and working partners are not covered unless the carrier accepts their written application by endorsement.

What is the penalty for not carrying coverage in Arizona?

Under A.R.S. 23-907, the ICA may assess a civil penalty of up to $1,000. A second failure within five years can bring up to $5,000, and a third up to $10,000. The ICA can also ask a court to close the business until it gets coverage. The ICA says an uninsured employer is guilty of a class 6 felony.

How do I dispute an Arizona workers' comp audit?

Work it out with the carrier first and pay the undisputed premium. Then use NCCI's dispute resolution process, or send a written request to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board at DIFI. You can appeal the Board's decision to the DIFI Director within 30 days after the Board mails it.

Important scope note

Practical prep guidance only.

This page summarizes Arizona rules published by the Arizona Legislature, the Industrial Commission of Arizona, the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions and NCCI for audit prep. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, it is not a ruling on your policy, and your policy, the Arizona manual and your carrier's audit are the final word.

Get your Arizona records in order before the audit

Start with the free checklist, check the likely bill with the estimator, or use the workbook to keep payroll, owner records and subcontractor certificates in one file.