Free dispute letter template

Workers' comp audit dispute letter: a sample you can copy

Got an audit bill you think is wrong? Copy this letter, list each item you dispute with the proof that fixes it, and ask the carrier for a revised bill or a re-audit.

Quick answer

To dispute a workers' comp audit bill, write to your carrier's premium audit department. Give your policy number and audit period, list each item you think is wrong, say what you believe is right, attach the record that proves it, and ask for a revised bill or a re-audit. Send it as soon as you can, keep a copy and copy your agent.

A dispute is strongest when each item has a record behind it: a certificate of insurance for a subcontractor, a payroll report that shows overtime separately, a policy endorsement that excludes an owner. The letter below is built around that. Check your bill line by line first so you only dispute what you can prove.

Rules and deadlines differ by state and carrier. If the carrier will not change the bill, the next step is usually your state's rating bureau and then the state insurance department. The state guides below give the path for six states.

Two words you will see on this site: to reconcile payroll means to check that your payroll totals match your tax forms (Form 941s, W-2s) for the same policy period. A crosswalk is a short table or note that maps each payroll and tax report to the policy period, so you and the auditor can see where each number comes from.

The dispute letter template

Replace everything in [square brackets]. Add one numbered block for each item you dispute, and delete any line that does not apply.

[Your business name]
[Street address]
[City, State ZIP]
[Phone] | [Email]

[Date]

[Insurance company name]
Premium Audit Department
[Address or audit email from your audit bill]

Re: Request for audit review and revised bill
Policy number: [policy number]
Audit period: [policy start date] to [policy end date]
Audit statement or invoice number: [number], dated [date]
Amount billed: $[amount]

Dear Premium Audit Department,

We received the final audit for the policy above. We compared it with our payroll, tax and subcontractor records and believe the items below are wrong. We ask you to review them and correct the audit.

Disputed item 1: [line on the audit, for example "Class 5645 Carpentry, payroll $84,000"]
What the audit shows: [audited amount, class code or treatment]
What we believe is correct: [your amount, class code or treatment]
Why: [one or two plain sentences, for example "This $84,000 was paid to ABC Framing LLC, which had its own workers' compensation policy for all of the time it worked for us."]
Evidence attached: [Exhibit A: certificate of insurance showing the policy number and dates; Exhibit B: list of payments to ABC Framing LLC]

Disputed item 2: [line on the audit]
What the audit shows: [ ]
What we believe is correct: [ ]
Why: [ ]
Evidence attached: [Exhibit C: ]

[Copy the block above for each further item.]

Undisputed amount: We do not dispute $[amount] of this bill. [We have paid it / We will pay it by (date).]

We ask you to:
1. Issue a revised audit and bill that reflects the corrections above, or arrange a re-audit of these items with an auditor who can review the records with us.
2. Send us the audit worksheets that show how each figure on the audit was calculated, including payroll by class code and any subcontractor amounts added.
3. Confirm in writing that you received this request and when we can expect an answer.

Please reply in writing by [date, for example 30 days from today]. If we cannot resolve this with you directly, we understand we may ask [the rating bureau for our state / the state insurance department] to review it.

Thank you,

[Your name]
[Title]
[Business name]

Enclosures: [Exhibit A: ], [Exhibit B: ], [Exhibit C: ]
cc: [Your insurance agent or broker]
  • Send it the way your audit bill or policy asks for correspondence, by email or an audit portal if it lists one. Certified mail gives you proof of the date. Keep a copy of everything you send.
  • Look for a dispute or review deadline on the audit bill and in your policy, and send the letter well inside it. If you cannot find one, ask your agent and send the letter anyway.
  • Paying the part you do not dispute keeps the policy from being cancelled for unpaid premium, and NCCI's dispute process (used in most states) asks for it before it reviews a dispute.
  • Number every attachment as an exhibit and name it in the item it supports, so the auditor does not have to guess which record proves what.
  • Only dispute what you can show. An item without a record behind it usually stays on the bill and can make the rest of the letter easier to dismiss.

What to write for the most common disputed items

Sample wording for the 'Why' line, and the record that usually settles each item. Your own facts go in place of the examples.

Disputed itemSample wording for the letterEvidence to attach
Subcontractor payments added as payroll"The $[amount] paid to [sub] was for work done while [sub] carried its own workers' compensation coverage."Certificate of insurance from the sub's carrier, naming the state and covering the dates of the work, plus the payment list for that sub
Payroll in the wrong class code"$[amount] of payroll for [employee or role] was placed in class [code]. Their work was [duties], which belongs in class [code]."Job descriptions, time records showing hours by type of work, and payroll split by class
Overtime counted at full pay"The audit includes the overtime premium of $[amount]. Our payroll records show it separately, and our state's rules exclude it."Payroll register with overtime premium in its own column. Check your state first: Pennsylvania, for example, counts all overtime pay
Owner or officer charged when excluded"[Name] is excluded from coverage by the endorsement on our policy, so their pay should not be in the premium."The exclusion endorsement or the state's exclusion or exemption form
Officer pay above the state limit"[Name]'s pay was counted at $[amount]. The state's maximum for an executive officer for this period is $[amount]."The officer's payroll and weeks active, and the state's published officer limits
Payroll from outside the policy period"The audit uses payroll from [months] that falls outside our policy period of [dates]."Payroll by month or quarter mapped to the policy dates
Bill based on an estimate because records were not sent"We did not complete the audit in time. We now attach the full payroll records and ask you to replace the estimate with an audit of these records."Everything the auditor asked for, with a note of what each file is
Experience mod on the audit differs from the rating worksheet"The audit applies a mod of [x]. The rating worksheet for this policy period shows [y]."The experience rating worksheet from your rating bureau or agent

Mistakes that weaken a dispute letter

  • Calling the whole bill wrong instead of naming the exact lines and amounts
  • Sending explanations without the records that prove them
  • Attaching a certificate of insurance that does not cover the dates the sub worked
  • Missing the deadline on the bill while gathering records, instead of writing first and sending more proof after
  • Leaving the undisputed part unpaid, which can lead to cancellation or collections
  • Writing angry or threatening language; a clear, short letter gets read and answered

Before you send the letter

  1. Ask the carrier for the audit worksheets if you only have the bill, so you can see payroll by class code and any subcontractor amounts.
  2. Check the bill line by line and mark each item you can prove is wrong.
  3. Gather one record for each item: certificates of insurance, payroll reports, endorsements, the rating worksheet.
  4. Fill in the letter, number your exhibits and add the undisputed amount.
  5. Send it before the deadline, copy your agent, and write down the date sent and when you will follow up.
  6. If the carrier says no, ask in writing for the reason and for the next step in your state.

If the carrier will not change the bill

The path differs by state. These are the usual steps; your state guide and the carrier's answer give the exact ones.

  1. Ask the carrier in writing for its reasons and for a review by an audit supervisor.
  2. Ask your agent or broker to raise the dispute with the carrier for you.
  3. Take a class code, payroll or experience mod dispute to the rating bureau for your state: NCCI in most states, or the state's own bureau, such as the WCIRB in California or the NYCIRB in New York.
  4. If that fails, appeal to the state insurance department. Ask the bureau how and by when.
  5. State guides with the dispute path for California, New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Texas and Florida are linked under the checklist above.

Keep reading

More on this topic

Check your audit bill

Each line of the audit report, what goes wrong on it and the proof that fixes it.

Learn more →

What payroll is included

Overtime premium, officers, subcontractors, tips, and per diem under general NCCI rules.

Learn more →

Arizona audit rules

NCCI rules, owner coverage, contractors and the appeals board.

Learn more →

California audit rules

The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.

Learn more →

Florida audit rules

Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.

Learn more →

Georgia audit rules

NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Frequently asked questions

Can you dispute a workers' comp audit?

Yes. Write to the carrier's premium audit department, list each item you think is wrong with the record that proves it, and ask for a revised bill or a re-audit. If the carrier will not change it, most states let you take it to the rating bureau and then the state insurance department.

Is there a deadline to dispute an audit bill?

Deadlines differ by carrier and state. Look on the audit bill and in your policy, ask your agent, and send the letter as soon as you can. You can send more proof after the letter if you are still gathering records.

Do I have to pay the bill while I dispute it?

Pay the part you do not dispute. Leaving the whole bill unpaid can lead to cancellation or collections, and NCCI's dispute process asks for the undisputed premium to be paid first.

What evidence works best?

Records made at the time: certificates of insurance that cover the dates a subcontractor worked, payroll registers that show overtime and job duties separately, policy endorsements, and the experience rating worksheet.

Can I ask for a re-audit?

You can ask. A carrier can review the audit or send it back to an auditor when you show records that were missed. Ask for it in the letter, as the template does.

Does this work in Ohio, Washington, North Dakota or Wyoming?

Those states run workers' comp through a state fund with their own audit and appeal rules. The letter still helps organize your case, but follow the state fund's process and deadlines.

Sources

Official rating bureau and state agency pages this guide is based on.

Important scope note

Practical prep guidance only.

This page gives general guidance for organizing an audit dispute. It is not legal or insurance advice, it does not promise any result, and your policy, your state's rules and your carrier's process are the final word.

Build the file the letter points to

Contractors: the Construction Kit's workbook has an audit results review tab and a dispute log, plus editable email templates. Restaurants, offices, shops and other small businesses: the SMB Edition has a result review sheet, a follow-up sheet and its own review and dispute guide. Either way, every item in your letter ties to a record.