Illinois workers' comp audit

Workers' comp audits in Illinois: coverage rules, owners and disputes

Illinois requires coverage from the first employee, fines employers who go without it, and gives you a path to the Department of Insurance if you disagree with your audit.

Quick answer

The Illinois Department of Insurance (IDOI) regulates workers' comp insurers. NCCI is a licensed rating organization that makes advisory rate and loss cost filings in Illinois. Every carrier must file its manuals of classifications and rules, its rating plans and its rates with IDOI. Your audit applies the class codes and rules your carrier filed. Ask your agent which manual and class codes your policy uses.

Illinois law lets sole proprietors, partners and LLC members choose not to be covered, except in extra-hazardous work such as construction and trucking. Bona fide corporate officers can withdraw from coverage by giving the carrier written notice.

Any employer with even one part-time employee must carry coverage. If you disagree with how the rating system was applied to you, the rating organization, or a carrier that sets its own rates, must give you a way to be heard. You can appeal its decision to the Director of Insurance within 30 days.

Email me the Illinois audit checklist

The free checklist PDF, plus how Illinois counts payroll at audit, in one email.

How Illinois rules affect your audit

From the Illinois Workers' Compensation Act, the Insurance Code and IDOI. Ask your agent about any payroll limits in your carrier's filed manual.

ItemIllinois ruleWhat to keep
Overtime and tipsCounted under the manual rules your carrier filed with IDOI. Ask your agent how overtime premium and tips are treated on your policyPayroll register with overtime premium and tips in their own columns
Executive officersAsk your agent whether your carrier's filed manual sets a minimum and maximum for officer payroll, and what the current figures areNames, titles, pay and weeks active
Corporate officersA bona fide president, vice president, secretary or treasurer can withdraw from coverage. The withdrawal takes effect when the carrier receives written noticeA copy of each officer's written withdrawal notice and the carrier's receipt
Sole proprietors, partners and LLC membersMay choose to be covered or not, but those in extra-hazardous work such as construction and trucking must have coverageYour written election and any policy endorsement
SubcontractorsIf you do construction, excavating or electrical work and hire a contractor or subcontractor for that work, you are liable to pay compensation to its employees unless it has insuranceCertificates of insurance for every subcontractor for the dates of the work
No coverageFines of up to $500 a day with a $10,000 minimum, work-stop orders, and criminal charges for owners and officersProof of continuous coverage for every day you had employees

Illinois-specific mistakes

  • Assuming a corporate officer is excluded when no written withdrawal notice was sent to the carrier
  • Assuming an owner or LLC member in construction or trucking can skip coverage
  • Hiring an uninsured subcontractor for construction work, which makes you liable for its employees
  • Thinking a single part-time employee does not require a policy
  • Missing the 30-day window to appeal a rating decision to the Director of Insurance
  • Lumping overtime premium and tips in with regular wages, so the auditor cannot apply your manual's rules to them

Illinois audit checklist

  1. Confirm you had coverage for every day you had an employee, including part-time staff.
  2. Pull payroll by employee and class for the policy period, with overtime premium and tips shown separately.
  3. List every owner, partner, LLC member and officer with pay and weeks active.
  4. Find each corporate officer's written withdrawal notice, and any owner's election, if they are not covered.
  5. Collect certificates of insurance for every subcontractor for the dates of the work.
  6. Ask your agent for the current executive officer payroll limits on your policy.
  7. Check the final audit results line by line against your records.

How an Illinois audit dispute works

From the Illinois Insurance Code, IDOI and NCCI's dispute resolution process.

  1. Try to resolve the dispute directly with your carrier, in writing, with the records that support your position.
  2. Pay the carrier all undisputed premium. NCCI's dispute process, where it applies, requires this before it will review a dispute.
  3. Ask in writing for a review of how the rating system was applied to you. The rating organization, or a carrier that sets its own rates, must give you a way to be heard. If it does not grant or reject the request within 30 days, you can treat it as rejected.
  4. Within 30 days of written notice of that decision, you can appeal to the Director of Insurance, who holds a hearing and may affirm or reverse it.
  5. You can also file a complaint with IDOI online or by mail. Call its Consumer Assistance Hotline at (866) 445-5364 for a complaint form.

Keep reading

More on this topic

Arizona audit rules

NCCI rules, owner coverage, contractors and the appeals board.

Learn more →

California audit rules

The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.

Learn more →

Florida audit rules

Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.

Learn more →

Georgia audit rules

NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Indiana audit rules

ICRB rules, officer elections, contractor certificates and disputes.

Learn more →

Maryland audit rules

NCCI rules, officer exclusions, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Frequently asked questions

Does Illinois require workers' comp insurance?

Yes. IDOI says an employer with even one part-time employee must provide workers' comp coverage. Family members must be insured too, unless they are bona fide corporate officers or work for certain agricultural businesses.

What happens if I do not carry coverage in Illinois?

For a knowing and willful failure, the Workers' Compensation Commission can fine you up to $500 a day, with a $10,000 minimum, and can issue a work-stop order. Owners, partners, LLC members and officers who negligently fail to insure face a Class A misdemeanor, and a knowing failure is a Class 4 felony.

Can a corporate officer opt out of coverage in Illinois?

Yes. A bona fide president, vice president, secretary or treasurer can withdraw by giving the carrier written notice. It takes effect when the carrier receives the notice. The officer can rejoin the same way.

Do sole proprietors and LLC members need coverage in Illinois?

They may choose to be covered or not. IDOI says those in extra-hazardous work, such as construction and trucking, must get coverage.

Am I liable for an uninsured subcontractor in Illinois?

Yes. Under the Workers' Compensation Act, if you do construction, excavating or electrical work and engage a contractor or subcontractor for that work, you are liable to pay compensation to its employees unless it is insured. Collect a certificate of insurance before work starts.

How do I dispute an Illinois workers' comp audit?

Work it out with the carrier first and pay the undisputed premium. Then ask in writing for a review of how the rating system was applied. You can appeal that decision to the Director of Insurance within 30 days, and you can file a complaint with IDOI.

Important scope note

Practical prep guidance only.

This page summarizes Illinois rules published by the Illinois Department of Insurance, the Illinois General Assembly and NCCI for audit prep. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, it is not a ruling on your policy, and your policy, your carrier's filed manual and your carrier's audit are the final word.

Get your Illinois records in order before the audit

Start with the free checklist, check the likely bill with the estimator, or use the workbook to keep payroll, officer notices and subcontractor certificates in one file.