Michigan workers' comp audit

Workers' comp audits in Michigan: CAOM rules, officers and disputes

Michigan is not an NCCI state, and each carrier files its own rules. Here is who needs coverage, how owners and officers count, and how to dispute an audit.

Quick answer

Michigan uses open rating. The Compensation Advisory Organization of Michigan (CAOM) collects data and publishes advisory pure premiums, but it may not set rules, rates or forms for the voluntary market. Each carrier files its own rules, class codes and rates with the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS). CAOM's sister, the Michigan Workers' Compensation Placement Facility, runs the assigned risk market and keeps the Basic Manual used there. Many carriers follow that manual, but ask your agent which rules your policy uses.

A private employer must carry coverage if it regularly employs three or more people at one time, counting part-time staff, or one person 35 hours or more a week for 13 weeks or longer in the last 52 weeks. Partners, corporate officers and LLC member-managers count as employees. A sole proprietor is never an employee of his or her own business.

If you disagree with your audit, work it out with the carrier first, in writing. Michigan's Insurance Code says each carrier must give you a way to be heard on how its rating system was applied to you. You can appeal its decision to the DIFS director within 30 days. Assigned risk policies also have an appeal to the Facility's Appeals Committee.

Email me the Michigan audit checklist

The free checklist PDF, plus how Michigan counts payroll at audit, in one email.

How Michigan counts payroll at audit

From the Workers' Disability Compensation Act, the Workers' Disability Compensation Agency (WDCA) and the Facility's Basic Manual and rating values. The manual and figures apply to assigned risk policies. Voluntary carriers may file different ones, so ask your agent.

ItemMichigan ruleWhat to keep
Who must carry coveragePrivate employers with three or more employees at one time, including part-time staff, or one employee working 35 hours or more a week for 13 weeks or longer in the last 52 weeksA headcount by month, with hours for part-time staff
Class codes and rulesEach carrier files its own manual, class codes and rates with DIFS. CAOM publishes the Facility's Classifications Manual and Basic Manual, which many carriers use as a modelA short description of what each employee actually does
Executive officers and active LLC membersFacility rating values set a minimum of $633 and a maximum of $2,500 a week for policies effective on or after 1/1/2026, and $667 and $2,700 a week for policies effective on or after 1/1/2027. Voluntary carriers may use other figures, so ask your agentNames, titles, pay and weeks active
Officer and LLC member exclusionsAn officer with at least 10% of the stock in a corporation with 10 or fewer stockholders, or a manager-member with at least 10% of an LLC with 10 or fewer members, may opt out. The election is a written notice to the carrier, with the company's consent endorsed on itA copy of each signed election notice and the exclusion endorsement
Partners and sole proprietorsPartners are covered unless excluded by endorsement. A sole proprietor is not covered. Under the Facility's rating values, a covered partner or sole proprietor's spouse is counted at a fixed $26,000 a year (1/1/2026) or $27,300 a year (1/1/2027)Your policy's exclusion endorsement, if any
Overtime and tipsUnder the Basic Manual, tips and gratuities are not payroll. The extra pay for overtime is left out if your records show it separately. If records show only total overtime pay at time and one-half, one-third of that total is left outPayroll register with overtime premium and tips in their own columns
SubcontractorsYou are liable for the employees of an uninsured subcontractor. Under the Basic Manual, if a subcontractor with employees has no certificate or filed exclusion form (WC-337), you pay premium on its payroll, or on the full subcontract price if you have no payroll recordsCertificates of insurance or WC-337 forms for every subcontractor for the dates of the work

Michigan-specific mistakes

  • Assuming NCCI rules apply, when your carrier files its own rules and class codes with DIFS
  • Leaving part-time staff out of the three-employee count
  • Assuming an officer or LLC member is excluded when no written election was sent to the carrier
  • Relying on a certificate of insurance from a sole proprietor with no employees as proof he or she is independent, when the auditor may ask for more
  • Hiring a subcontractor with employees that has no certificate or WC-337 exclusion form, so its payroll or full contract price lands on your audit
  • Lumping overtime premium in with regular wages, so the auditor cannot take the extra pay out
  • Ignoring audit requests, which on assigned risk policies can bring a charge of up to twice the estimated annual premium

Michigan audit checklist

  1. Ask your agent which manual, class codes and officer payroll figures your carrier filed for your policy.
  2. Count everyone you regularly employ, including part-time staff, partners, corporate officers and LLC member-managers.
  3. Pull payroll by employee and class for the policy period, with overtime premium and tips in separate columns.
  4. List every officer and LLC member with pay and weeks active, and find any written election to be excluded.
  5. Collect a certificate of insurance or WC-337 exclusion form from every subcontractor with employees.
  6. For sole proprietor subcontractors with no employees, keep proof they run a separate business, such as an FEIN, a written contract, 1099s and a sworn statement that they have no employees.
  7. Check the final audit results line by line against your records.

How a Michigan audit dispute works

From the Michigan Insurance Code, the WDCA, DIFS and the Facility's Basic Manual.

  1. Try to resolve the dispute directly with your carrier, in writing, with the records that support your position. If the auditor charged you for a subcontractor without accepting your proof, the WDCA says to ask the carrier in writing for another payroll audit.
  2. Pay the undisputed part of the bill. For assigned risk policies, the Facility will not bind coverage if you owe undisputed premium or did not comply with an audit.
  3. Ask the carrier in writing to review how its rating system was applied to you. Michigan law says it must give you a way to be heard. If it does not grant or reject the request within 30 days, you can treat it as rejected.
  4. Within 30 days of written notice of that decision, you can appeal to the DIFS director, who holds a hearing on at least 10 days' written notice and may affirm or reverse it.
  5. For an assigned risk policy, you can also appeal a Facility staff decision to its Appeals Committee, in writing, at least 15 days before the meeting. You can then appeal to the Insurance Commissioner within 30 days of the Committee's written decision.
  6. You can also file a complaint with DIFS online or by mail. Call 877-999-6442 for help.

Keep reading

More on this topic

Arizona audit rules

NCCI rules, owner coverage, contractors and the appeals board.

Learn more →

California audit rules

The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.

Learn more →

Florida audit rules

Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.

Learn more →

Georgia audit rules

NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Illinois audit rules

One-employee rule, officer opt-outs, uninsured subs and appeals.

Learn more →

Indiana audit rules

ICRB rules, officer elections, contractor certificates and disputes.

Learn more →

Frequently asked questions

Does Michigan require workers' comp insurance?

Yes, for private employers that regularly employ three or more people at one time, including part-time staff, or one person 35 hours or more a week for 13 weeks or longer in the last 52 weeks. Partners, corporate officers and LLC member-managers count as employees.

Does Michigan use NCCI class codes?

No. Michigan is not an NCCI state and uses open rating. Each carrier files its own rules, class codes and rates with DIFS. CAOM publishes the Placement Facility's Classifications Manual and Basic Manual for the assigned risk market, and many carriers use them as a model. Ask your agent which codes your policy uses.

What are the Michigan executive officer payroll limits?

For assigned risk policies, the Facility's rating values set a minimum of $633 and a maximum of $2,500 a week for policies effective on or after 1/1/2026, and $667 and $2,700 a week for policies effective on or after 1/1/2027. The same limits apply to active LLC members. Voluntary carriers may file other figures, so ask your agent for the figure on your policy.

Can owners and officers opt out in Michigan?

An officer who owns at least 10% of a corporation with 10 or fewer stockholders, or a manager-member who owns at least 10% of an LLC with 10 or fewer members, may opt out by written notice to the carrier with the company's consent endorsed on it. Partners can be excluded by endorsement. A sole proprietor is not covered by the policy at all.

What is the penalty for not carrying coverage in Michigan?

An employer that fails to comply is guilty of a misdemeanor and may be fined up to $1,000, jailed for up to 6 months, or both. Each day without coverage is a separate offense. An injured employee can also sue the employer, and a corporation's officers and directors can be held personally liable for amounts the state recovers.

How do I dispute a Michigan workers' comp audit?

Work it out with the carrier first, in writing, and pay the undisputed part. Then ask the carrier in writing to review how its rating system was applied to you. You can appeal its decision to the DIFS director within 30 days. For assigned risk policies, you can also appeal to the Facility's Appeals Committee and then to the Insurance Commissioner.

Important scope note

Practical prep guidance only.

This page summarizes Michigan rules published by CAOM, the Michigan Workers' Compensation Placement Facility, the Workers' Disability Compensation Agency, DIFS and the Michigan Legislature for audit prep. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, it is not a ruling on your policy, and your policy, your carrier's filed manual and your carrier's audit are the final word.

Get your Michigan records in order before the audit

Start with the free checklist, check the likely bill with the estimator, or use the workbook to keep payroll, officer elections and subcontractor certificates in one file.