North Carolina workers' comp audit

Workers' comp audits in North Carolina: NCRB rules, subcontractors and disputes

North Carolina has its own rating bureau, the NCRB, and its own Basic Manual. Here is how the audit counts payroll, what contractors owe for uninsured subs, and how to dispute an audit.

Quick answer

North Carolina has its own rating bureau. The North Carolina Rate Bureau (NCRB) files workers' comp loss costs and assigned risk rates with the Commissioner of Insurance and publishes the North Carolina Basic Manual. Audits follow that manual's payroll and classification rules.

Under the manual the extra part of overtime pay is excluded when your records show it separately, voluntary tips are excluded, and service charges and automatic gratuities count as payroll. Executive officers count at a minimum and maximum payroll set in the manual's Miscellaneous Values section, which changes each year. Ask your agent for the current figure.

Most employers with three or more employees must carry coverage, and some need it with just one. A contractor who sublets work without getting a certificate of insurance from the sub first can be liable for the sub's injured workers, so uninsured subs show up on your audit.

Email me the North Carolina audit checklist

The free checklist PDF, plus how North Carolina counts payroll at audit, in one email.

How North Carolina counts payroll at audit

From NCRB's North Carolina Basic Manual, Rule 2, and the NC General Statutes. Officer limits change each year.

ItemNorth Carolina ruleWhat to keep
OvertimeThe extra part of overtime pay is excluded when the records show it separately: the difference between the regular and overtime rate times the overtime hours. For double time recorded separately, one half of the double time pay is excludedPayroll register with overtime premium in its own column
TipsTips the customer chooses to give are excluded. Service charges and automatic gratuities set by the business are payrollTip reports kept apart from service charges
Executive officersCounted at the minimum and maximum individual payroll in the manual's Miscellaneous Values section. Ask your agent for the current figureNames, titles, pay and dates active
Owners and LLC membersSole proprietors, partners and LLC members are not covered unless they are active in the business, elect in and the insurer is notified. If they elect in, payroll is a set amount from Miscellaneous ValuesA copy of any election and the policy endorsement
Officer exclusionsA corporation can exclude an executive officer by naming that officer as excluded in the policy. The exclusion lasts for the policy periodA copy of the exclusion in the policy
Uninsured subcontractorsA contractor who sublets work without first getting a certificate of insurance from the sub can be liable for the sub's employees. At audit, premium is added for the sub's workers, based on the sub's payroll records or on the subcontract priceCertificates of insurance dated before each sub started, plus contracts and invoices

North Carolina-specific mistakes

  • Working from NCCI's national manual, when North Carolina audits follow the NCRB's North Carolina Basic Manual
  • Lumping service charges in with tips, or tips in with wages
  • Collecting a sub's certificate of insurance after the sub has already started, instead of before you sublet the work
  • Assuming an owner or LLC member is covered without an election on file, or excluded when they elected in
  • Thinking a business with fewer than three employees never needs coverage, when work involving radiation needs it with one
  • Waiting too long to answer NCRB's request for documents in a dispute. After 45 days the matter is closed

North Carolina audit checklist

  1. Count your regular employees and confirm you need coverage (three or more, or one or more for radiation work).
  2. Pull payroll by employee and class for the policy period, with overtime premium shown separately.
  3. Separate voluntary tips from service charges and automatic gratuities.
  4. List every officer with pay and dates active, and find any officer exclusion in the policy.
  5. List every sole proprietor, partner or LLC member and whether they elected coverage.
  6. Collect a certificate of insurance for every subcontractor, dated before the sub started work.
  7. Check the final audit results line by line against your records.

How a North Carolina audit dispute works

From Rule 6 of NCRB's North Carolina Basic Manual.

  1. Try to resolve the dispute directly with your carrier, in writing, with the records that support your position. If it cannot be resolved, the carrier has a duty to tell you about NCRB's dispute resolution services.
  2. Send the dispute to NCRB in writing (wcdisputes@ncrb.org). It covers disputed premium, who is covered by the policy, class codes and experience mods.
  3. NCRB asks you and the other parties for documents. Send yours within 45 days, or the matter is closed. You can ask NCRB in writing for more time if you have good cause.
  4. If the parties still cannot agree, any party can ask in writing for a hearing. The hearing officer mails a written decision within 30 days after the hearing closes. Ask NCRB about any further review in your case.

Keep reading

More on this topic

Arizona audit rules

NCCI rules, owner coverage, contractors and the appeals board.

Learn more →

California audit rules

The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.

Learn more →

Florida audit rules

Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.

Learn more →

Georgia audit rules

NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Illinois audit rules

One-employee rule, officer opt-outs, uninsured subs and appeals.

Learn more →

Indiana audit rules

ICRB rules, officer elections, contractor certificates and disputes.

Learn more →

Frequently asked questions

Who has to carry workers' comp in North Carolina?

Most employers that regularly employ three or more people in the same business. An employer with even one employee needs coverage if the work involves radiation. Farm work and domestic service are generally excluded, but a farm employer that regularly employs 10 or more full-time nonseasonal farm workers needs coverage.

Does North Carolina use NCCI class codes?

North Carolina has its own rating bureau. The North Carolina Rate Bureau (NCRB) files loss costs and assigned risk rates with the Commissioner of Insurance and publishes the North Carolina Basic Manual that audits follow. The manual uses NCCI material with permission, but check your class codes against the North Carolina manual, not the national one.

What are the North Carolina executive officer payroll limits?

The minimum and maximum are set in the Miscellaneous Values section of NCRB's Basic Manual and change each year. Ask your agent for the current figure for your policy's effective date.

Am I liable if my subcontractor has no workers' comp?

You can be. Under G.S. 97-19, a contractor who sublets work without first getting a certificate of coverage, issued by the sub's insurer (or a Department of Insurance certificate of compliance if the sub is self-insured), can be liable for the sub's injured workers. You are not liable if the sub had its own policy in effect on the date of injury. Your audit can still add premium for any sub without proof of coverage.

What is the penalty for not carrying coverage?

The NC Industrial Commission can assess a civil penalty of $1 per employee per day, at least $20 and no more than $100 a day. If you have not been penalized before and you then buy coverage, you can ask the Commission to replace it with a penalty based on the cost of that coverage, plus 10%. Willful failure is a Class H felony, and negligent failure is a Class 1 misdemeanor. You also stay liable to injured employees.

How do I dispute a North Carolina workers' comp audit?

Work it out with the carrier first, in writing. If that fails, send the dispute to NCRB in writing. NCRB gathers documents from both sides, and any party can ask for a hearing. The hearing officer issues a written decision within 30 days after the hearing.

Important scope note

Practical prep guidance only.

This page summarizes North Carolina rules published by the North Carolina Rate Bureau and the NC General Statutes for audit prep. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, it is not a ruling on your policy, and your policy, the North Carolina Basic Manual and your carrier's audit are the final word.

Get your North Carolina records in order before the audit

Start with the free checklist, check the likely bill with the estimator, or use the workbook to keep payroll, officer pay and subcontractor certificates in one file.