Virginia workers' comp audit

Workers' comp audits in Virginia: NCCI rules, officers and disputes

Virginia uses NCCI's manuals and class codes. Here is who needs coverage, how officers, LLC managers and owners count, and how to dispute an audit.

Quick answer

Virginia is an NCCI state. NCCI is a licensed rating organization that files loss costs and assigned risk rates with the Bureau of Insurance, and its Basic Manual for Virginia sets the class codes and audit rules. Your premium depends on your class codes, your payroll and your loss history. Questions about class codes go to the Bureau of Insurance, not the Workers' Compensation Commission.

A business with more than two part-time or full-time employees must carry coverage. Executive officers and LLC managers count as employees, and so do a subcontractor's workers when the subcontractor does your trade or helps fulfill your contract. An executive officer or LLC manager may reject coverage by filing Form 16A. Sole proprietors, partners and LLC members are not covered unless they elect coverage with the carrier.

If you disagree with your audit, work it out with the carrier first and pay the undisputed premium. Then use NCCI's dispute process. Virginia law also lets anyone aggrieved by how a rating system was applied ask the carrier or rating organization, in writing, to be heard, and then appeal to the State Corporation Commission within 30 days of its written decision.

Email me the Virginia audit checklist

The free checklist PDF, plus how Virginia counts payroll at audit, in one email.

How Virginia counts payroll at audit

From the Code of Virginia, the Workers' Compensation Commission and NCCI's Virginia instructions. Ask your agent for the officer payroll limits that apply to your policy date.

ItemVirginia ruleWhat to keep
Who must carry coverageAny business with more than two part-time or full-time employees. Executive officers count, and so do the workers of subcontractors who do your trade or help fulfill your contractA headcount by month, with part-time staff, officers and subcontractor crews listed
Class codesNCCI files Virginia's class codes, loss costs and assigned risk rates with the Bureau of Insurance. Class code questions go to the Bureau of InsuranceA short description of what each employee actually does
Executive officersCounted as employees even without a regular salary. Virginia's official pages do not publish the officer payroll minimum and maximum, so ask your agent for the figures in effect for your policy dateNames, titles, pay and weeks active
Officer and LLC manager rejectionsAn executive officer or LLC manager may reject coverage for accidents, but not occupational disease, by Form 16A. It goes to the employer and is filed with the Commission. Payroll is excluded for those who reject. Directors and LLC members cannot rejectA copy of each Form 16A and proof it was filed with the Commission
Sole proprietors, partners and LLC membersNot covered unless they elect coverage by written notice to the carrier. If they elect, their payroll is included. NCCI treats LLC members like sole proprietors and partners for premium. A member who also works for pay as an employee may count as an employeeYour written election, if you chose coverage
Independent contractorsA 1099 does not decide status. If you control how the work is done, the worker may count as your employee. Uninsured contractors can be charged at auditProof of coverage for every contractor and subcontractor for the dates of the work

Virginia-specific mistakes

  • Leaving part-time workers or executive officers out of the headcount when checking the more-than-two-employees rule
  • Forgetting that a subcontractor's workers can count toward your total when they do your trade
  • Assuming an officer or LLC manager is excluded when no Form 16A was given to the employer and filed with the Commission
  • Trying to exclude a regular employee, a director or an LLC member, which Virginia does not allow
  • Assuming a sole proprietor, partner or LLC member is covered without a written election to the carrier
  • Paying a contractor on a 1099 without proof of coverage, then getting charged for that contractor at audit
  • Disputing an audit without first paying the undisputed premium, which NCCI's process requires

Virginia audit checklist

  1. Count everyone you employ, including part-time workers, executive officers, LLC managers and the crews of subcontractors who do your trade.
  2. Pull payroll by employee and class for the policy period, with overtime premium shown separately.
  3. List every officer and LLC manager with pay and weeks active, and find any Form 16A on file with the Commission.
  4. If you are a sole proprietor, partner or LLC member, find your written election of coverage, if you made one.
  5. Collect proof of coverage for every contractor and subcontractor for the dates of the work. The Commission's Insurance Coverage Search tool can help you check.
  6. If you are a contractor, ask your agent about the Contracting Classification Premium Adjustment Program. NCCI must get the application within 180 days after policy inception.
  7. Check the final audit results line by line against your records.

How a Virginia audit dispute works

From NCCI's dispute resolution process and the Code of Virginia, § 38.2-1923.

  1. Try to resolve the dispute directly with your carrier, in writing, with the records that support your position.
  2. Pay the carrier all undisputed premium that is due, and give it an estimate of the premium in dispute with a written explanation.
  3. If that fails, ask NCCI to review it through its dispute resolution process (disputes about class codes, payroll allocation and the experience mod). An NCCI consultant tries to help you and the carrier reach a resolution.
  4. If it is still not resolved, NCCI can send it to an appeals board. The board's written decision explains how and where to appeal.
  5. Under Virginia law, you may also ask the carrier or rating organization in writing to be heard on how its rating system was applied to you. If it does not act within 30 days, you can treat the request as rejected.
  6. You may appeal its action to the State Corporation Commission within 30 days after written notice of it. The Commission holds a hearing and may affirm or reverse.

Keep reading

More on this topic

Arizona audit rules

NCCI rules, owner coverage, contractors and the appeals board.

Learn more →

California audit rules

The WCIRB's rules, officer limits, dual wage classes and disputes.

Learn more →

Florida audit rules

Construction exemptions, subcontractor proof and disputes.

Learn more →

Georgia audit rules

NCCI rules, officer waivers, owner coverage and disputes.

Learn more →

Illinois audit rules

One-employee rule, officer opt-outs, uninsured subs and appeals.

Learn more →

Indiana audit rules

ICRB rules, officer elections, contractor certificates and disputes.

Learn more →

Frequently asked questions

Does Virginia require workers' comp insurance?

Yes, for any business with more than two part-time or full-time employees. Executive officers count toward that number, and so do the workers of subcontractors who do your trade or help fulfill your contract.

Does Virginia use NCCI class codes?

Yes. NCCI is a licensed rating organization in Virginia and files loss costs and assigned risk rates with the Bureau of Insurance. For questions about your class codes, the Workers' Compensation Commission points you to the Bureau of Insurance.

What are the Virginia executive officer payroll limits?

Virginia's official public pages do not publish them. Ask your agent whether a minimum and maximum apply to officer payroll on your policy, and what the figures are for your policy date.

Can owners and officers opt out in Virginia?

An executive officer or LLC manager may reject coverage for accidents, but not occupational disease, by giving Form 16A to the employer and filing a copy with the Commission. Directors, LLC members and regular employees cannot reject. Sole proprietors, partners and LLC members are not covered unless they elect coverage in writing with the carrier.

What is the penalty for not carrying coverage in Virginia?

The Commission may assess a civil penalty of up to $250 a day, up to $50,000, plus collection costs. If the failure continues after notice, the Commission may order the business to stop operating until it complies.

How do I dispute a Virginia workers' comp audit?

Work it out with the carrier first and pay the undisputed premium. Then use NCCI's dispute resolution process, which can send the dispute to an appeals board. Virginia law also lets you ask the carrier or rating organization in writing to be heard, and then appeal its action to the State Corporation Commission within 30 days.

Important scope note

Practical prep guidance only.

This page summarizes Virginia rules published in the Code of Virginia and by the Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission, the Bureau of Insurance and NCCI for audit prep. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, it is not a ruling on your policy, and your policy, the Virginia manual and your carrier's audit are the final word.

Get your Virginia records in order before the audit

Start with the free checklist, check the likely bill with the estimator, or use the workbook to keep payroll, officer pay and subcontractor proof of coverage in one file.